Use this tool to quickly find the best insurance rates.

Protect your family, home and auto with the right insurance

Insurance Made Simple

Understand your coverage choices quickly and easily.

Compare Rates & Save

Receive customized quotes with no obligation to buy.

Expert Guidance

Get professional guidance on all your insurance questions.

How much do you qualify for?

No Obligation. No Credit Check.

Why Choose Preferred-Protectors Insurance Agency?

Secure your future with the right insurance.

Superior Service

Quality of service is our core focus, and it is the very foundation of our business.

We’re Tailored To You

Forget one-size-fits-all insurance. Get the exact protection you need, right when you need it most.

Dedicated Agents

You will receive dedicated service from a professional agent who will work to find you the best available rate and coverage.

Your Insurance professionals in Fairfield

The Preferred-Protectors Insurance Agency Team is your local source for risk control services and insurance solutions. We take pride in offering five-star support to all our customers throughout the Cincinnati Tri-State area. Our experienced agents have the expertise to customize policies for your auto, home, health, and business insurance requirements.

We believe in a partnership approach that creates a lasting relationship with each of our customers. Our goal is to provide the right coverage at the lowest possible cost. The time is now to put the Preferred-Protectors Insurance Agency team to work for you. Contact us today for a FREE assessment for your current coverage needs.

GET A QUOTE TODAY

Our numbers speak for themselves

0+

Years Experience

$0B

Coverage Provided

0%

Customer satisfaction rate

Secure the best coverage and rates with our dedicated team

The Preferred-Protectors Insurance Agency Team is committed to providing clients with the highest quality insurance plans available combined with some of the lowest rates available in all of the Cincinnati Tri-State area. Whether you’re shopping for auto insurance, home insurance, health, life or business insurance, this site can help get you the best coverage available with the lowest rate possible.

Preferred-Protectors Insurance Agency offers unparalleled service and competitive quotes to clients throughout the entire Cincinnati Tri-State area!

View Products

Our services are built to simplify your insurance search.

Efficiency

We streamline the process to quickly find the best insurance options for you.

Clarity

 We'll educate you so you truly understand your coverage and choose what's best for you.

Value

We help you find the right insurance, saving you money and securing the best coverage.

  • Chris Nieto has been our family insurance professional since 2005. He has provided the best service, hands down, of any agent ever. He responds to insurance policy questions... read more

    Katie Edwards Avatar Katie Edwards
    July 15, 2021

    I've trusted the Preferred-Protectors team with my insurance needs for over 10 years. They are deeply responsive to changes in the market rates, and the needs of my family to... read more

    Craig Jones Avatar Craig Jones
    July 15, 2021

    Chris Nieto and Preferred Prorectors have worked with our insurance needs for over 18 years with no problems! Any time we call Chris is quick to reply, he keeps looking... read more

    Joel Hopkins Avatar Joel Hopkins
    July 15, 2021

  • Chris Nieto has taken care of my insurance needs for 20 years. Chris is always professional and does a great job taking care of me and my family. Chris is... read more

    Mike Lawson Avatar Mike Lawson
    July 15, 2021

    We have insured with Preferred Protectors Agency for many years, they are very professional and have taken great care of us.

    Brad Jones Avatar Brad Jones
    July 15, 2022

    Insurance is a lot more complex than I ever imagined. However, Chris Nieto at Preferred-Protectors Insurance Agency has been there each and every time I've need coverage. Chris has been... read more

    Alex Wagner Avatar Alex Wagner
    July 15, 2021

Comprehensive Insurance Solutions for Your Peace of Mind

Our insurance services are designed to make your experience smooth and stress-free.

Tailored Coverage Plans

Find the insurance plan that fits your needs perfectly.

Customizable Policies

Adjust your coverage to match your lifestyle and needs.

Transparent Terms

Understand your policy clearly with our straightforward explanations.

GET A QUOTE TODAY

Explore our frequently asked questions

We offer a wide range of insurance plans, including auto, home, health, life, and business insurance.

You can easily get a personalized quote by using our online tool or contacting one of our agents directly.

Yes, we offer bundling options that can save you money when you combine multiple insurance policies.

Absolutely. Our policies are flexible, allowing you to choose the coverage that best fits your needs and budget.